

The Good: Darren Helm (132nd overall, 2005) – A terrific selection in the 5th round, Helm’s NHL experience in his first two seasons was mostly in the playoffs. The speedster is in a great position to replace and carry on the tradition of Kirk Maltby and Kris Draper as an elite 2-way, forechecking, penalty killing dynamo. Just for good measure, Helm added 11 goals and 24 points as well.
The Bad: Thomas McCollum (30th overall, 2008) – Now before people start complaining that I’m taking a guy who just made his pro debut this past season, let me explain. First, the Red Wings haven’t really made a mistake in the the early rounds of the last 5 years and even the players that haven’t played in the NHL yet, they’re still in the picture and it would be premature to label them as busts. So why McCollum then? He was horrible at the 2009 WJC for USA and this past year his AHL stats were far from impressive (30 GP, 10 wins, .881 SV% an 3.48 GAA). My last reason? Jacob Markstrom, the near concensus top goalie outside the NHL, was taken 1 pick later.
The Unknown: Jakub Kindl (19th overall, 2005) – The former Kitchener Ranger import has now played three years on the farm in Grand Rapids and has back-to-back 33 point campaigns on his resumé. Does Nicklas Lindstrom’s signing negatively impact a possible promotion for Kindl?

Draft Trends: Detroit has drafted this high only once since 1991 so it’s tough to find a 1st round trend. In the last 7 years, Detroit’s first picks (not necessarily 1st rounders) by position have been 2 goalies, 2 defencemen and 3 forwards. The Red Wings always take a Swede at some point in the draft but not always in the early stages and they pick from other European countries too. CHL, NCAA, Europe... all at pretty much the same rate. There really is no big pattern to Detroit’s choices. The Wings have recently invited guys who didn’t get drafted to their prospect camp and have come away signing both Raedeke and Willie Coetzee that way.
2010 Prediction 21st overall:
Dean Millard: Jonathan Merrill (NTDP) - Merrill almost played in the USHL as a 15-year-old before heading to the U.S. National program. He’s a big stay at home defenceman but at 6’3 and 200 lbs he has to play more physical than he does. He also hasn’t shown a lot of offensive ability but if he had either of the latter 2 attributes he’d be a top ten guy. Maybe a team thinks he has that stored away and will take him much higher, but I see him as a steady stay at home type. That will work for the Wings.

No comments:
Post a Comment