~

The debate has raged on for months now, especially here in Edmonton where the local club has the ultimate say on who will go #1 at the 2010 NHL Entry Draft. The Edmonton
Oilers will put a new face on their franchise on Friday in Los Angeles when they select either Taylor Hall of Tyler
Seguin with the first overall pick.
The argument has gained a considerable amount of steam beginning with the end of the NHL season, it picked up more when Plymouth and Windsor met in the
OHL playoffs, ratcheted up another notch after the Memorial Cup and higher still over the last few weeks. It's no longer a friendly discussion anymore; if one fan voices his preference for either player there seems to be a gang of supporters ready to pounce in defence of
their guy.
I've been very public about what I would do and who I would select if I were in their position (
Seguin) but I've also tried to be clear in stating that I don't think the
Oilers can really make a mistake. That might sound like I'm on the fence - I'm not, I'd attempt to get something from Boston to lay off of Hall and take
Seguin. But if Edmonton opts for Hall, and that seems to be the general consensus and what my own digging suggests, then I don't believe that choice is really an error.
A couple of months ago Dean and I were talking with
Wil Fraser and Corey Graham, the hosts of
Sports Night which can be heard live after
The Pipeline Show, and I suggested that choosing between Hall or
Seguin was like deciding on whether you preferred a blond or brunette.
Wil expanded on that analogy and to borrow from him, here is exactly how I see the debate between the two potential franchise players summed up in a single picture: