Showing posts with label Thomson (Ben). Show all posts
Showing posts with label Thomson (Ben). Show all posts

Friday, March 13, 2009

The Springfield Golden Bears

Ever notice that when a new coach joins a organization, often times his former players will begin showing up as well? Mike Keenan has been around a lot and has played on a lot of different teams and it seemed to me like everywhere he went, Brian Noonan and Stephane Matteau were soon to follow. From Chicago to New York, St. Louis to Vancouver... sometimes players and coaches just have a certain chemistry and it makes sense.

Look at Brian Burke and Brad May; Vancouver, Anaheim and now Toronto.

Anyway, I was thinking about players that the Oilers could acquire next year to help out on the farm that would be (a) inexpensive and (b) familiar with the coach and that obviously leads to alum from the University of Alberta.

I hear what some of you are saying... "Um... CIS sucks, if those guys were any good they'd be playing in the AHL or something already."

I'm not going to try and change your mind on the quality of CIS hockey, you either believe it's crap or you see it as another developmental league that is no worse than on par with the ECHL (and quite possibly better than that). In my mind there are a number of solid players that come out of CIS, and the Golden Bears program specifically which is almost 100% comprised of former WHL grads. Many of those players are of the 'late bloomer' category that had they gone the NCAA route and graduated as 22-year-olds would have benefited. The CBA allows NHL clubs to hold the rights of their NCAA prospects until after graduation which obviously is a huge plus for players who need extra time to develop or recover from early career inuries.

I'm going to throw some names at you but keep in mind that two things would have to be taken in to consideration of which I don't know the answer to at the present time. The first is the contract status of the players I'm about to mention and the second is that I am assuming Rob Daum is the coach in Springfield next year. So assuming Daum is behind the bench and these players are all available, here's a few guys I think could have success in the AHL under the watch of their former CIS coach.

I'll start with Ben Thomson who had a 5-year career in Medicine Hat with the Tigers during which he had a trio of +70-point seasons and scored 31, 32 and 40 goals. Thomson played just three years for Alberta before turning pro but at the CIS school he was a standout scoring 43 points in 36 games as a rookie and following it up with 53 points in 44 games and then 54 points in 43 games in his final year.

It was in the National Final game at Rexall Place in 2005 where Thomson scored two remarkable goals. With his club trailing by a goal when Thomson would tie the game with a goal that former NHL GM Craig Button described to me by saying "That was a NHL caliber goal". Solidifying his mythic status in CIS lore, Thomson would then go on to score the O.T. winner giving the home team the National Title.

Thomson stuck around for one more year, won another Championship, then bolted for the AHL where he would play under one Rob Daum in Houston. Thomson appeared in 47 games and recorded 22 points, a pace for 38 points in a full 82-game AHL season. By comparison that pace would put him easily in the top 5 scorers in Springfield this year and keep in mind that was his rookie campaign.

Currently, Thomson is in Germany playing for Ravensburg Tower Stars in the 2nd Bundesliga, a step down from the DEL (German Elite League). As you would expect a player of any quality to do in such a league, Thomson is piling up the points. Last year he recorded 50 points in 35 games and so far this season he has 40 points in 27 games.

The pros are obvious; an offensive player that has been able to translate his WHL success to the pro level. The only con I can perceive is Thomson's size. At 5'7 and 180 lbs he's obviously not a big guy. However, if current Medicine Hat Tiger Tyler Ennis has a NHL future and other pint sized players like Justin Azevedo are proving they can play in today's North American pro game I think it's worth exploring Thomson as an option.

Next on my list is defenceman Harlan Anderson who actually had a brief stint with the Falcons last year. Anderson was an offensive minded blueliner in Moose Jaw and continued in that mold for 5 years at the UofA.

When he joined Springfield last year it looked like a perfect fit; an offensive puck-moving defenceman for a team that had none and couldn't get out of their own end. Unfortunately the former Bear struggled under Kelly Buchberger and played sparingly during his 9 AHL games.

On one occasion Anderson attempted to make a play up the ice and was criticized for his efforts when he returned to the bench. According to the person who told me about the incident, the coach snapped and practically mocked the former Bear for trying to 'play a CIS style game in the AHL'. The always consistent WHL and CIS scorer failed to register a single point during his short Springfield stint.

Subsequently Anderson looked to Europe this year and like Thomson, landed in the 2nd Bundesliga but with the Heilbronn Falcons. Not suprisingly, in Germany he has once again shown his ability to produce and has 26 points in 43 games.

Anderson was the go-to guy on the power play for the Moose Jaw Warriors and the Alberta Golden Bears. His smooth skating and accurate passing at those levels are what NHL teams covet at the top and evidently the player is still capable of being an effective offensive player. Anderson will be 27 next October and will have 6 years experience playing against men.

Another player worth considering is Dylan Stanley who I believe, but could be wrong, was recruited to the UofA by Daum before he left for the AHL. Stanley's first of three years as a Golden Bear was under coach Eric Thurston who assumed Daum's spot. Stanley had 93 points in his third WHL season with the Tri-City Americans and scored 34 goals in back-to-back years as well.

Stanley tore up Canada West as a UofA rookie when he totalled 24 goals and had a team high 58 points in 44 games. He helped the Bears win another National Title that year and captured another with Alberta last season before turning pro.

There appears to be a pipeline between the UofA and Germany and Stanley followed it, landing with the Rosenheim Star Bulls in the Oberliga. That league is another step down from the one Thomson and Anderson are in and as such, you would expect Stanley to be able to put up some decent numbers even as a rookie. Well you'd be right. In 54 games the Edmonton native has a whopping 110 points, clearly too good for the league he's in.

He's not big either although he's not as short as Thomson. Still, 5'10 and 182 lbs raises the usual questions regarding an ability to compete in a North American pro rink. Still... with that amount of production, what's the downside to a tryout?

Finally, here are some other Golden Bears past and present who might be worthy of consideration:

- Ian Mcdonald was a Kyle Brodziak like 92-point man in his final WHL year and at 6'3 and 200 lbs could provide a power forward presence at the AHL level.

- Aaron Sorochan was arguably the best goalie at Oilers camp a couple of Septembers ago and is only getting better with age. He's picked up a pile of CIS hardware for his individual performances and should be worthy of a pro contract when his UofA days are done.

- Ben Kilgour is to the Golden Bears as Ryan Smyth was to the Oilers; a heart and soul player willing to sacrafice his body in front of the net or in the corners. He's has enjoyed three +40-point years at the UofA and his eligibility runs out at the end the month.

- Tim Krymusa spent 5 seasons with the Spokane Chiefs and then 5 more at the UofA. He's a talented 2-way guy who is also playing in Germany this year and has 29 goals and 65 points in 55 games for Passau Black Hawks in the Oberliga.

- Brad Tutschek is a former Daum player at the UofA and is playing in the DEL for the third straight year. At the UofA he was one of Daum's most dangerous offensive weapons.

Like I said before, I know many of you reading this will discount these players for their CIS background and even now playing in Germany. Consider this; Ryan Huddy was given a tryout and subsequently signed a contract this year after playing in Germany for two seasons. His stats? You can see for yourself that he simply does not measure up to the players I have listed above. Obviously his name bar played a role in getting the camp invite but... does that mean he didn't earn the contract based on his camp performance?

There are some talented players listed above and many of them enjoyed their best years playing for Rob Daum. Why wouldn't camp invites next year make a lot of sense? Clearly it couldn't fail any worse than the status quo in Springfield.

Monday, February 18, 2008

Policy on NHL Rights Needs Changing


One thing that has always bugged me is the way NHL teams can hold onto the rights of NCAA players until they're graduated but for CHL players it's decision time after just 2 years from draft day.

Does anyone know the reason for this? Honestly, I'm asking because I don't. It just makes zero sense to me.

You draft a 17 year old from Moose Jaw who is playing in the WHL for Kamloops and by the time he's 19 you have to decide whether or not he's worth offering a contract to. On the other hand, if that same kid at 17 was playing for the Notre Dame Hounds while waiting to join the Denver Pioneers as a 19-year-old freshman, the NHL club wouldn't have to even think about him until he'd graduated at the age of 23.

19 if you play Major Junior in Canada... 23 if you play NCAA in the States. Same kid, two completely different situations.

What if that 17 year old has a major shoulder injury as an 18-year-old and spends his 19-year-old season getting back into form but only puts up 50 points for the Blazers? That's probably a kid that doesn't get an offer from his NHL team (just ask Eric Hunter).

Meanwhile, in the other scenario, that same kid has 4 more years to get back into top form before he has to worry about getting dumped by the NHL team that drafted him. Hell, at 18, his college career hasn't even begun yet, he's still playing in the SJHL or the BCHL or maybe stateside in the USHL. (see Oiler draft pick Robby Dee)

What about the classic late bloomer who doesn't hit his stride until he's 20, or 22 for that matter? How many guys do you see not getting drafted but get signed as a 20-year-old free agent at the end of their CHL career or as a undrafted NCAA grad?

LOTS.

It's a joke.

If I were boss of the world, NHL teams would be able to keep the rights to their CHL players until their eligibility was up and then even beyond that provided the player in question is committed to enrolling and playing for a CIS program.

Canadian Universities have outstanding scholarship programs; the WHL is the biggest contributor to scholarships in Western Canada, and most of the players playing in the Canada West Conference of CIS hockey now have WHL backgrounds. Many of those players were drafted as 17 or 18-year-olds but never signed once their CHL eligibility expired.

Every year I get told by NHL scouts that CIS hockey is the best kept secret in the hockey world and that several players across the country could play at the AHL level, if not higher.

My solution would see many of the players skating for the Alberta Golden Bears, the Saskatchewan Huskies, the Acadia Axemen, etc still with the ties to the NHL teams that drafted them. It would give those players a longer opportunity to realize their dreams, the NHL teams a longer period of time to wait for development of late bloomers and it just might encourage more 20-year-old CHL grads to continue with their education while playing hockey.

By the way, the guy in the picture is Ben Thomson. This is a guy who was 5 years ahead of his time. In a world where mini-mights like Patrick Kane are not only NOT overlooked at the draft but selected 1st overall despite being 5'8 and 160 lbs... Ben Thomson wasn't even considered a potential prospect. His 3 consecutive +70 point, +30 goal seasons deemed unworthy of recognition because they were achieved by a player outweighed by many bantam players.

After his impressive years with the Medicine Hat Tigers, Thomson joined the University of Alberta Golden Bears where he continued to shine scoring well over a point per game in each of his 3 seasons. In the National title game Thomson scored the tying goal in the dying seconds and then the overtime winner to give Alberta it's record setting victory.

From Alberta it was on to the AHL where Thomson caught on with the Houston Aeros, a team coached by his former Alberta bench boss Rob Daum. 22 points in 47 games as a rookie should be considered a success but with Daum leaving the team, so did Thomson's chances and it was off to Europe for 2007-08.

The German 2nd division is a far cry from the best European leagues but 41 points in 27 games should be enough to impress anyone.

Why use Thomson as my example? As a 20 year old coming off the final outstanding year with Medicine Hat, a NHL team should have been able to "draft" or "list" Thomson because he was headed to play CIS hockey with Alberta. That would have given him the opportunity to attend a NHL camp each fall, compete for a pro job and safely return to school should he fail to get one knowing that the opportunity would be there again next fall.

The only down side that I can see to this idea is that NHL teams are only allowed to have 80 names on their protected list, 50 of which are under contract. But if it meant expanding that 80 to 85 or 90... what would be the harm in that?

No really... I'm asking. Am I off base here or does this not make sense for everyone involved? NHL teams benefit, the players benefit, CIS hockey benefits... who doesn't?